Diamond Pro is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn More.
In order to get the highest value for your diamond trade-in or upgrade, we recommend you contact Abe Mor’s Diamond Buying Program. Due to their extensive expertise and connections within the diamond industry, Abe Mor is your best bet for getting top dollar with the least amount of headaches. You can securely ship your diamond to Abe Mor from anywhere in the world.
Read our Selling Your Diamond article to be as prepared as possible.
Have you been thinking about when to upgrade your engagement or diamond ring? Whether you have an engagement ring that’s been passed on from your mom or grandma, or you just want to upgrade to a larger center stone or switch to a different cut, it’s becoming increasingly common to upgrade your diamond ring over time.
No matter your situation, plenty of options are available for upgrading or trading in a diamond ring. There are vendors who specialize in upgrading rings and trading in diamonds, as well as ways to ensure you receive the highest value.
As for how long it takes to upgrade an engagement ring? As long as you use the right vendor, you generally won’t need to wait for longer than you would if you simply ordered a new stone and setting.
You may desire to upgrade or trade in your diamond for a number of reasons. You may want to:
Before pursuing such options, ensure you understand the trade in process. You want to maintain the most value for your diamond and choose a path that will give you the best final result: a diamond ring you love.
Our guide will show you:
Upgrading your diamond or engagement ring is usually a fairly easy process. However, the best approach depends on several factors, the most important of which is where you bought the ring in the first place.
For example, if you or your partner bought your engagement ring from Blue Nile, James Allen or Brian Gavin Diamonds, we recommend using their respective upgrade programs. These allow you to trade in your old diamond and upgrade to a new one without any extra fees or surcharges.
We’ve covered these programs in more detail below, in our section on the best diamond dealers for trading in and upgrading a diamond.
If you or your partner bought your ring from a local jewelry store, you’ll usually need to sell the diamond before you can upgrade to a larger one. We’ve also explained the best options for this in the section below, along with our tips to help you get the best deal.
As for the various ways in which you can upgrade your ring, your options include:
Your engagement ring is a deeply personal item, meaning there’s no “perfect” way for everyone to upgrade their ring. Pick the upgrade option that best suits your tastes, personality and budget and you’ll end up with a beautiful piece of jewelry that’s uniquely yours.
Trading in your diamond at just any vendor or jewelry store can be detrimental. If you’re not careful and haven’t done the research, it’s likely you’ll receive far less than the maximum value for the ring (or, honestly, anywhere close to it).
Many diamond vendors have trade-in policies, but that doesn’t mean they’re good policies. While the offers may seem great at first glance, many of the companies that offer full value upgrades are companies that ripped you off to begin with. Even if a company is offering a “full upgrade” or “the full value of the original purchase price,” it’s simply not a good deal if the diamonds they sell are of poor quality.
For example, lets say you originally purchased your diamond from Shane Co. You may think it is the better route for your trade-in because you get the full value for your original purchase. But you’ll end up overpaying on the new diamond by an obscene amount—meaning you’ll end up losing money in the end. We call that: “throwing good money after bad.” Your original purchase from them was likely less than stellar. By going with them for a trade-in, you miss the opportunity to find an extraordinary upgraded diamond, all while putting your money toward an overpriced diamond.
Both brick and mortar stores and online vendors can pull these tricks. That’s why the vendor you choose for your diamond upgrade or trade-in is extremely important.
We recommend going with a diamond vendor that offers excellent value from the start. Our extensive experience and working with a range of diamond dealers has shown us which vendors you can trust.
The vendors below are highly trustworthy and reputable options for your upgrade.
We highly suggest using Abe Mor Diamonds for your diamond ring upgrade or trade-in. They offer a secure shipping program that allows you to send your diamond to them from anywhere in the world. Abe Mor’s highly experienced diamond experts will examine your diamond and make you an offer that’s likely to exceed any amount you’ll receive elsewhere. Their longstanding relationships with jewelry retailers gives them insight into market pricing—translating to higher offers for you. You can find our full Abe Mor review here.
The Blue Nile Diamond Upgrade Program offers a lifetime diamond upgrade program on all AGSL and GIA graded diamonds. They maintain the largest online inventory of diamonds and settings and emphasize remarkable diamond quality. Trading in or upgrading your diamond ring with Blue Nile ensures you’re getting a high-quality diamond at an excellent price. You can read our full review of Blue Nile here.
James Allen offers a Lifetime Upgrade program where diamonds can be exchanged at 100% credit for any replacement diamond of at least 2X or greater value. James Allen is known for their phenomenal customer service and appealing prices. Their website utilizes advanced diamond imagery, allowing you to verify that your new diamond is truly stunning. Read our full review of James Allen here.
Brian Gavin offers their Lifetime Upgrade Policy which allows your Brian Gavin Signature diamond value to be put toward your upgrade. The “Brian Gavin Signature” Hearts & Arrows collection presents super-ideal cuts—giving you the most brilliant diamonds, especially for 3 Carat, 4 Carat and 5 Carat Diamonds. Read our Brian Gavin review here.
When you trade in a diamond, you want to get the highest value possible. You don’t want to be cheated or ripped off—like the many people who don’t know where to go for their trade-in.
The best way to get the maximum value for your trade-in is to find the company that offers the top dollar for buybacks. Not only should you seek the top dollar, but find a convenient trade-in option that works for you.
That’s why we so highly recommend Abe Mor’s Diamond Buying Program. Many of our readers have had exceptional experiences with selling their diamonds to Abe Mor. They received the highest offer possible—and ultimately gained peace of mind knowing that they got the value they deserved.
In our eyes, Abe Mor doesn’t even have competition when it comes to selling diamonds. They’re uniquely positioned to handle diamond upgrades and trade-ins. For instance, one of the first trade-in readers we sent to Abe Mor found the perfect fit. The reader upgraded their 4ct diamond to a gorgeous 8.50ct diamond, and Abe Mor even built them a stunning ring for the stone.
We’ve reviewed other major online sites that you can sell your ring to, and they didn’t even come close. Abe Mor even offers to pay for the insured shipping of the ring in order for them to inspect it. They also consistently offer higher prices than any of their competitors. Combining that with their professionalism is a winning scenario.
The best way to sell your diamond is to contact Abe Mor directly. They’re your best bet for getting top dollar with the least amount of headaches. Be sure to read our Selling Your Diamond article to be as prepared as possible.
In order to determine the value of the diamond you’d like to sell or trade in, you need to get a professional assessment from a reputable and trustworthy buyer (we suggest Abe Mor). To be sure you’re getting the best deal, read the instructions below to learn how to calculate how much your diamond is worth.
Follow our expert guide for finding the best value for your diamond:
Follow these steps to ensure you get the top value for your diamond and that you end up with a stunning, new ring from a reputable seller.
It’s important to understand that your diamond’s resale worth will be nowhere close to what you paid for it. We explain the reasons why fully in our article about selling diamonds.
The two main reasons you’ll not receive the value of what you originally paid:
Our goal is for you to end up with the most exceptional diamond ring at an excellent price. We want you to get the best trade-in value and find a new diamond ring that’s stunning.
The best way to get the most beautiful diamond ring is to spend in the areas that greatly affect a diamond’s beauty, and scale back in the areas that won’t be noticed by the naked eye.
To do this, we recommend reviewing the diamond yourself or having an expert assist you.
Follow our expert recommendations when searching for your new diamond:
Make sure you get the absolute best value for your trade-in or upgrade. Choose the Abe Mor Diamond Buying Program or a reputable vendor with an upgrade policy like James Allen, Blue Nile or Brian Gavin.
When in doubt, reach out to us and we’ll walk you through every step of the trade-in and upgrade process.
Before you buy a diamond, get personal buying advice from industry veterans. We'll help you get the best diamond for the money.
DISCLAIMER: We don't use your email for marketing. Period.
We are a team of diamond experts who will teach you to identify scams and avoid spending money on features you can't see. Tell us as much information as possible to help us help you (ie, budget, preferences, etc)
DISCLAIMER: We don't use your email for marketing. Period.