We get commissions for purchases made from our affiliates through links in this article. Learn More.
When it comes to diamond clarity, the main goal is to find an eye-clean diamond. This means that no blemishes or inclusions are visible when you look at the diamond yourself. With eye-clean diamonds, it doesn’t matter what imperfections you can see under magnification. You—and everyone else—won’t be looking at your engagement ring through a jeweler’s loupe.
Learning how to spot an eye-clean diamond takes time—and knowing what to look for. You won’t be able to determine if a diamond is eye-clean from its certificate alone. You’ll have to evaluate each diamond more closely yourself.
Knowing how to find an eye-clean diamond at a lower clarity grade—such as a VS2 or SI1—can save hundreds or thousands of dollars off of your engagement ring budget. You’ll pay less than you would for a higher-graded diamond like an IF diamond, but still get one that’s eye-clean. In the end, they look identical, and you’ll pay much less.
Learn more about eye-clean diamonds and how to shop for one.
Eye-clean diamonds don’t have any inclusions and blemishes that are visible to the naked eye. Under magnification, they have imperfections, but not when you look at it without a jeweler’s loupe.
To see if a diamond is eye-clean, you need to look at it closely under HD photography or videography, like what’s provided by James Allen. When shopping in bricks and mortar stores, look at the diamond away from the overly bright sales lights. Ideally, you should review the diamond in natural daylight.
There isn’t a specific clarity grade that guarantees an eye-clean diamond. For instance, a VS2 doesn’t necessarily mean it’s eye-clean, but in many cases, it is, like in this Round Cut pave engagement ring.
SI1 diamonds can be eye-clean, like this 1.00 Carat Radiant Cut diamond. Even SI2 diamonds can be eye-clean, but it’s less common. That’s why it’s so important to evaluate the clarity of the diamond yourself. The size, color and number of inclusions all impact the visibility of imperfections at the eye level.
Want to find an eye-clean diamond at the lowest price point? Follow these expert tips for your diamond search.
While the grade that the GIA or AGS gives out for clarity is important, it’s not the only tool you should use for evaluating a diamond. Generally, diamonds in the VS and SI ranges will give you the best value for an eye-clean diamond.
If it’s a VVS, FL or IF diamond, you’re paying too much for clarity (unless you’re going for a diamond over 3 carats, then a VVS might be your best value). These are the higher grades, and you can almost always find an eye-clean diamond for less. On the other hand, I1-I3 diamonds are simply too included to be eye-clean in any carat weight above 0.4ct.
For reference, the GIA grades clarity on the following scale:
Review the photos and videos thoroughly to see if you notice any blemishes and inclusions. They offer the ability to zoom in and see where the inclusions are but remember you won’t be looking at the diamond under magnification when it’s in your ring.
If you’re shopping in-person, review the diamond in normal light—ideally daylight—to see if you notice any imperfections.
Even if a diamond has blemishes and inclusions, you want to understand where they’re located. If they’re near the edge of the diamond, the ring setting is likely to cover them. If there’s a dark blemish in the middle of the diamond’s table, like in the diamond below, it won’t be covered. In fact, it’ll stand out each time you look at the diamond.
While a better clarity graded diamond might seem like the best choice, it isn’t worth the cost. A higher graded diamond will look identical to a lower graded diamond as long as they’re both eye-clean. For example, you can find diamonds like this beautiful SI2 that saves you almost 18% over this VS2 one.
t can be tough to evaluate a diamond’s clarity, especially if you’ve never done it before. Having an expert who’s reviewed thousands of diamonds can help you determine if it’s eye-clean. Reach out to us if you want us to take a look at some diamonds for you.
The shape and carat weight of your diamond impact what clarity grade is most likely to be eye-clean. Follow these guidelines to get the most value.
Round Cut and Princess Cut: For diamonds, less than 2 Carat, VS2 and SI1 diamonds are almost always eye-clean (sometimes even SI2s for a round cut). For diamonds over 2 carats, VS1s and VS2s are eye-clean. When your carat weight gets over 3 carats, you may have to look at VVS2 diamonds to get an eye-clean stone. The bigger the diamond (carat weight can play a role), the easier it is to see imperfections.
Cushion Cut, Oval Cut, Radiant Cut, Marquise and Pear-Shaped: These diamond shapes hide inclusions better than others. Opt for an SI1 or SI2 for the best value.
Heart-Shaped: VS2 and SI1 heart shape diamonds will be eye-clean and offer you the most for your budget. They hide inclusions better than Round Cuts and Princess Cuts, but not as well as shapes like the Cushion Cut.
Emerald Cut, Asscher Cut and Baguette: It’s easier to see imperfections in step cut diamonds. Aim for a VS2 in these shapes for the best value.
Evaluating diamonds to get the best value takes time and research. Here we answer the top questions about eye-clean diamonds.
Almost all VS2 diamonds that are 1 carat or less are eye-clean (but you still can’t take this for granted). Diamonds between 1 and 2 carat are usually still eye-clean but you may have to jump up to a VS1. For diamonds over 2 carats, consider VS1 and even VVS2 diamonds for eye-clean stones.
The diamond above is a stunning example of an eye-clean VS2 diamond ring.
I1 diamonds are generally not worth buying, especially for the center stone in an engagement ring, because there will be obvious inclusions. These inclusions and blemishes not only distract from the beauty of the stone, they also impact how well light travels through the diamond. Most I1 diamonds lack brilliance and fire.
For diamonds under 0.5 carat, such as the small stones in a pave band, I1 diamonds are a fine purchase. The diamonds are too small to see the imperfections, so you can save money by choosing I1 diamonds at this size vs. paying for a higher clarity grade.
The diamond inclusions that can be seen by the naked eye are the worst, and that usually involves inclusions that are particularly dark, large, or in the center of the diamond’s table. In some cases, a cluster of smaller inclusions will make the diamond appear cloudy.
There are many types of inclusions, from graining to feathers, but you need to review the diamond closely yourself to see if you can notice the imperfections without magnification.
Real diamonds can be cloudy (read more about cloudy diamonds here) if there are inclusions clustered together or if the fluorescence of the diamond is too strong. Real diamonds can also be cloudy if they have a build-up of grime and residue from normal wear. That’s why it’s important to care for your diamond engagement ring. Cleaning your ring regularly helps your diamond to look clear and to reflect light well (so it maintains its brilliance).
Your goal with diamond clarity should be to find a stone that’s eye-clean. A low-graded eye-clean diamond looks identical to a flawless graded diamond assuming all else is equal—but will cost far less. To get the best value, look for an eye-clean diamond in the lowest grade.
For help finding an eye-clean diamond at the best price, send us a note.
Before you buy a diamond, get personal buying advice from industry veterans. We'll help you get the best diamond for the money.
DISCLAIMER: We don't use your email for marketing. Period.
We are a team of diamond experts who will teach you to identify scams and avoid spending money on features you can't see. Tell us as much information as possible to help us help you (ie, budget, preferences, etc)
DISCLAIMER: We don't use your email for marketing. Period.